The marketing for Ebenezer has some people wondering whether Johnny Depp is playing a younger version of Scrooge in an origin story.
After all, Paramount’s promotional campaign has been teasing audiences with lines like “Before he was Scrooge, he was Ebenezer” and “The name you know, the story you don’t.”
Add horror director Ti West to the equation, and there are two perfectly reasonable questions to ask before buying a ticket: Is this actually a Scrooge prequel, and just how scary is it?
The short answer to the first question is no. Ebenezer is just another adaptation of Charles Dickens’ A Christmas Carol, not a story about how a young man became the miser we all know. The longer answer is that West and screenwriter Nathaniel Halpern have added some material to Scrooge’s past, but the familiar Christmas Eve ghost story remains very much intact.
The film follows Dickens’ original five-stave structure, taking Scrooge through the supernatural journey that forces him to confront his past, present and possible future. Johnny Depp plays the wealthy businessman whose hatred of Christmas and general contempt for humanity have made him one of literature’s most recognizable misers.
Ian McKellen plays Jacob Marley, while Andrea Riseborough, Tramell Tillman and Robert Strange portray the three spirits who arrive to give Scrooge the worst Christmas Eve of his life.
There is one notable addition that may help explain some of the prequel confusion. The movie opens with a sequence set seven years before the events of Dickens’ novella, showing Scrooge and Marley working together before Marley’s death. Arthur Conti plays the younger Ebenezer, and the opening gives the pair’s relationship more attention than the original book does. But once that prologue is over, the story settles into the familiar territory of A Christmas Carol.
So if you were expecting an elaborate new backstory explaining how Ebenezer became Scrooge, you may be disappointed. The title and promotional taglines suggest a bigger reinvention than the film actually delivers. This is a gothic-flavored retelling with some additions, not a new chapter in the Scrooge mythology.
How Scary Is Ti West’s Ebenezer?
That’s probably the more interesting question for anyone familiar with Ti West’s horror résumé. The director made his name with films including The House of the Devil, and the Mia Goth trilogy that includes X, Pearl and MaXXXine. Those aren’t exactly movies most parents associate with a cozy holiday outing.

Fortunately, Ebenezer doesn’t take the story into R-rated slasher territory. The film carries a PG-13 rating for frightening material, and its horror comes primarily from the supernatural encounters and the disturbing appearance of the spirits. West leans into gothic atmosphere, unsettling imagery and a style that recalls the old Hammer Horror movies. It looks and feels considerably darker than many traditional adaptations of Dickens’ Christmas classic.
That doesn’t mean families should assume the PG-13 rating is just a formality. Andrea Riseborough’s Ghost of Christmas Past has been singled out by critics for its particularly unnerving appearance, while the Ghost of Christmas Present gets some grotesque visual touches of its own. The film also makes the Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come a genuinely imposing presence.
Reviews have described moments that could frighten younger viewers, even though the movie stops short of the extreme violence associated with West’s better-known horror films. In other words, this isn’t Pearl with a Christmas tree, but it isn’t necessarily the version of A Christmas Carol I’d put on for very young children either.
Parents looking for a little more guidance should know that the PG-13 rating is specifically for frightening material. The film runs approximately 116 minutes, giving West plenty of time to make Victorian London feel like a rather unpleasant place to spend Christmas Eve.
Who Is Daisy Ridley Playing, and Who Is the Final Ghost?
The cast has generated a few questions of its own. Daisy Ridley’s character has been identified inconsistently in some online cast listings, with both Emily Cratchit and Clara appearing as possible names. Paramount’s official cast guide identifies Ridley as Clara, the wife of Scrooge’s nephew Fred, played by Sam Claflin. Some other cast listings have used Emily Cratchit, so Clara is the name to go with when following the studio’s official information.

There’s also a small literary curiosity buried in the supporting credits. Michael Culkin is listed as playing a character named Mr. Drood. Anyone familiar with Dickens may recognize that surname from The Mystery of Edwin Drood, the author’s final, unfinished mystery novel. It’s an interesting possible nod, although there’s no confirmation that the character was deliberately included as an Easter egg.
And while McKellen’s Jacob Marley, Riseborough’s Ghost of Christmas Past and Tillman’s Ghost of Christmas Present have received plenty of attention, the final spirit has been easier to overlook. Creature performer Robert Strange plays the Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come, the silent, hooded figure who shows Scrooge the grim fate awaiting him if he refuses to change.
That last visit is traditionally one of the darkest parts of A Christmas Carol, and West has the perfect opportunity to make it especially unsettling. The ghost doesn’t need to say much. Its job is to show Scrooge exactly where his miserable life is headed, and that’s frightening enough.
Ultimately, Ebenezer is much closer to a traditional A Christmas Carol adaptation than its origin-story marketing might suggest. The movie adds a little more to Scrooge and Marley’s history, but it doesn’t reinvent the character or replace Dickens’ familiar story. The bigger departure is the atmosphere. With Ti West directing, this Christmas ghost story has a few more nightmares tucked into its stocking than the average holiday movie.