Movies

‘Can‘t Hardly Wait‘ Cast Campaign For a Class Reunion Legacy Sequel

Can't Hardly Wait Class Reunion Sequel

The class of 1998 may be getting back together. Peter Facinelli and Joel Michaely are making a public push for a Can’t Hardly Wait legacy sequel, hoping Sony Pictures or a streaming service like Netflix, will help bring the cast back for a reunion movie ahead of the original teen comedy’s 30th anniversary in 2028.

Facinelli has been particularly busy trying to get the idea moving. After bringing back his character, Mike Dexter, for a Halloween video earlier this month, the actor is now using social media to get some familiar names involved. In a new post on X, Facinelli asked, “Who Can’t Hardly Wait for a reunion movie?” and tagged Netflix, Kenan Thompson, Jennifer Love Hewitt, Seth Green, Ethan Embry, Michaely and Sony Pictures.

That is quite a guest list for a party that hasn’t even been planned yet. Facinelli’s Halloween video featured him reprising the role of Mike Dexter, the arrogant high school jock who believed he had the world figured out. Michaely also appeared in the clip, which helped renew interest in seeing the Huntington Hillside High crowd again. Facinelli previously told TMZ that the internet was still talking about the video weeks after he posted it.

“A Can’t Hardly Wait sequel is the one high school reunion everyone actually wants to go to. Would be so fun to get the whole gang back together and see where they ended up,” Facinelli said.

He also joked that LoveBurger might finally get to play a song, while Mike Dexter could have another shot at winning back Amanda Beckett, played by Hewitt.

Michaely, who played one of the film’s X-Phile nerds, is also encouraging fans to make their interest known. He said people have been asking for a reunion movie for years and believes the 30th anniversary is the right time to make it happen. His suggestion is for Sony to produce the movie or partner with a streaming service such as Netflix or Amazon. In other words, the cast wants fans to let the studios know that this is a reunion worth attending.

There may already be some conversations happening behind the scenes. Producer Johnny Ryan Jr., whose credits include Good Burger 2, previously told Entertainment Weekly that he and Saturday Night Live star Kenan Thompson have spoken with cast members about producing a reunion. That doesn’t mean a sequel is in development, however. There has been no official announcement from Sony or a streaming platform.

The idea has support from another important member of the original cast. Hewitt said back in 2019 that she wanted to make a sequel and was even interested in directing it. Speaking on the Everything Iconic with Danny Pellegrino podcast, she said she was “dying to” make another movie and really wanted to direct it. She also mentioned that friends still dress up as characters from Can’t Hardly Wait every Halloween.

Released in 1998, the original movie followed a group of high school seniors during their graduation-night party. Preston Meyers (Ethan Embry) hoped to finally tell Amanda Beckett (Hewitt) how he feels about her, while Mike Dexter (Facinelli) is busy dealing with the sudden collapse of his carefully maintained high school reputation. The ensemble also included Seth Green, Lauren Ambrose, Charlie Korsmo, Selma Blair, Jason Segel, Melissa Joan Hart, Jerry O’Connell, Donald Faison, Jaime Pressly, Clea DuVall, Leslie Grossman, Breckin Meyer, Sara Rue and Sean Patrick Thomas.

A sequel would have plenty of history to work with, especially where Mike Dexter is concerned. The original film’s closing text explained that his glory days didn’t exactly translate into a successful adulthood. He lost his football scholarship and eventually wound up working at a car wash before being fired. A return to Huntington Hillside nearly three decades later could give the former king of the school a very different kind of entrance.

The Can’t Hardly Wait cast is clearly interested in revisiting those characters. Whether Sony or a streaming service wants to throw the reunion remains the big question. With 2028 approaching, the class of ’98 has a pretty good reason to start making plans.