I’m about to jump in the car and drive to the local repertory cinema to watch Planes, Trains and Automobiles. The Whiteside Theater has decided this is the ultimate Thanksgiving movie to show the week of the holiday. They’re playing the John Hughes classic both Sunday night, to help ease the stress faced in the days ahead, and again on Wednesday (Thanksgiving Eve) to prepare us all for the fight we face. I’ve seen the comedy, which stars Steve Martin and John Candy, too many times to count. For many, it’s become a Thanksgiving tradition. But it got me thinking.
Is it really the BEST Thanksgiving movie of all time?
If it’s not, then what is? Thanksgiving isn’t like Christmas, where we’re drowning in a sea of cinematic turkey legs and movie mashed potatoes. We’re not even getting a true Thanksgiving movie in 2026. Focker-in-Law is being promoted as such, but it only includes one scene revolving around the holiday. So what else is contending for the title of Best Thanksgiving Movie of All Time?
Most Thanksgiving movies are family comedies. There are a couple of horror flicks that involve the feast-filled celebration. There are practically no action or thrillers about the pursuit of a turkey. Using my handy Gobble-Ometer, I’ve sourced the top contenders to wear the crown, along with where you can watch them this year.
Addams Family Values (1993) | 1 hr 34 min
Why It Beats Planes, Trains and Automobiles: The Addams family has a new arrival, and Wednesday isn’t exactly thrilled about becoming a big sister. After baby Pubert joins the household, Gomez and Morticia hire a nanny named Debbie, who seems like the perfect person to help out. Unfortunately, Debbie has a few secrets of her own. She’s actually a serial killer with a plan to marry Uncle Fester, get her hands on the family fortune and eliminate anyone who gets in her way. Wednesday and Pugsley are shipped off to Camp Chippewa, where they’re forced to participate in wholesome summer activities that make them want to commit several acts of holiday-season rebellion.
The real Thanksgiving showdown happens when the camp puts on its annual holiday pageant. Wednesday is cast as Pocahontas, and the production turns into a wonderfully savage takedown of the traditional Thanksgiving story. While Planes, Trains and Automobiles gives us a frantic journey toward a family holiday, Addams Family Values asks what happens when the people forced to celebrate Thanksgiving decide they’ve had enough of the whole thing. Christina Ricci practically owns the movie during that pageant, and her performance alone makes this one worth considering.
Turkey Meter: 🦃 4.0/10: Thanksgiving doesn’t take over the entire movie. Most of the holiday action is packed into the Camp Chippewa pageant, but Wednesday makes those few minutes count. Let’s just say the Pilgrims probably wouldn’t have enjoyed this particular history lesson. It’s a pretty low turkey score, but the scene is so good that it earns a place on the list.
Where to Watch: Addams Family Values is available to stream on Paramount+. You can also rent it digitally through Amazon Video, Apple TV and Plex.
Home for the Holidays (1995) | 1 hr 43 min
Why It Beats Planes, Trains and Automobiles: Claudia Larson (Holly Hunter) is having a rough year. She’s just lost her job, her teenage daughter is growing up faster than she’d like, and her Thanksgiving plans involve heading back to her childhood home to spend the holiday with her wonderfully dysfunctional family. Her mother (Anne Bancroft) is determined to make the gathering special, her father (Charles Durning) is doing his best to keep the peace, and her sister (Cynthia Stevenson) has brought along a husband who seems to have perfected the art of being irritating. Then there’s Tommy (Robert Downey Jr.), Claudia’s unpredictable younger brother, who has a habit of making an already uncomfortable family gathering even more entertaining.
Directed by Jodie Foster, Home for the Holidays gets right into the messy business of Thanksgiving. Forget the travel nightmares. This is about what happens after you finally arrive and discover that being home can be every bit as stressful as getting there. The old family arguments and uncomfortable dinner-table moments feel painfully familiar. Planes, Trains and Automobiles makes you want to reach your destination. This one might make you reconsider telling your family you’re coming at all.
Turkey Meter: 🦃 9.5/10: Thanksgiving is the entire reason this family is together. The holiday gets plenty of screen time. There’s turkey preparation and dinner that threatens to become a family intervention. We’re treated to the sort of post-meal chaos that makes you grateful when somebody else volunteers to do the dishes. If you’ve ever survived Thanksgiving with relatives, this movie may feel less like fiction and more like a documentary.
Where to Watch: Home for the Holidays is available to stream on Paramount+, MGM+ and free with ads on Pluto TV. You can also rent it through Amazon Video or Apple TV.
Thanksgiving (2023) | 1 hr 46 min
Why It Beats Planes, Trains and Automobiles: After a Black Friday riot at a Plymouth, Massachusetts, big-box store ends in tragedy, somebody decides the town needs a little more holiday punishment. A year later, a killer wearing a John Carver Pilgrim mask begins targeting the people connected to the disaster. As the body count rises, the residents discover that their Thanksgiving celebrations are about to get a whole lot uglier.
Directed by Eli Roth, Thanksgiving takes the holiday’s obsession with family traditions and overeating, then runs it through a meat grinder. John Candy and Steve Martin never had to worry about being carved up by a homicidal Pilgrim during their trip home.
Turkey Meter: 🦃 10/10: You really can’t get more Thanksgiving than this without stuffing a turkey under the killer’s mask. The movie takes place in Plymouth, Massachusetts, and gives us a Pilgrim-masked murderer, a Thanksgiving parade, Black Friday madness and a dinner-table finale that makes you think twice about asking for seconds. This is the rare Thanksgiving movie where the bird isn’t necessarily the most dangerous thing on the table.
Where to Watch: You can stream Thanksgiving on HBO Max or Hulu. If you’d rather rent it, look for it on Amazon Prime Video, Apple TV or Fandango at Home.
Pieces of April (2003) | 1 hr 20 min
Why It Beats Planes, Trains and Automobiles: April Burns (Katie Holmes) has a Thanksgiving plan, and for once, she’s trying to do something nice for her family. The problem is that April isn’t exactly the favorite child. She’s been estranged from her parents and siblings, and inviting them to her New York apartment for Thanksgiving dinner is her attempt to patch things up. There’s just one little problem: she has absolutely no idea what she’s doing in the kitchen. When her oven breaks down with the turkey still needing to be cooked, April has to enlist the help of her apartment neighbors before her family arrives.
While Planes, Trains and Automobiles turns getting home into an epic comedy of errors, Pieces of April finds its trouble waiting in the kitchen. This is a scrappy little indie comedy-drama about a family trying to reconnect, with April’s Thanksgiving dinner threatening to fall apart before anyone even sits down. It’s funny and surprisingly heartfelt. You might even find yourself rooting for April to get that turkey cooked.
Turkey Meter: 🦃 9.0/10: The entire movie revolves around Thanksgiving dinner. April’s broken oven kicks off a race against the clock, sending her on a scavenger hunt through her apartment building in search of someone who can cook a turkey. Meanwhile, her family is making its way to her place, completely unaware of the culinary disaster waiting for them. If the Turkey Meter measured how much screen time is devoted to getting a bird on the table, this one would be close to maxing it out.
Where to Watch: Pieces of April is available to stream free with ads on Tubi, The Roku Channel, Pluto TV and YouTube. You can also rent it through Amazon Video.
Tower Heist (2011) | 1 hr 44 min
Why It Beats Planes, Trains and Automobiles: Josh Kovaks (Ben Stiller) manages a luxury apartment building where the wealthy residents have it pretty good. One of them, billionaire Arthur Shaw (Alan Alda), has been trusted with the employees’ retirement savings. When Shaw is exposed as a crook and loses everyone’s money, Josh and his fellow workers discover that their pensions may be gone for good. With the help of a street-smart criminal named Slide (Eddie Murphy), they hatch a plan to break into Shaw’s heavily secured penthouse and steal back what they’re owed. Their target? A fortune hidden inside one of New York’s most expensive buildings.
Directed by Brett Ratner, Tower Heist swaps the road-trip misery of Planes, Trains and Automobiles for a high-rise caper, with a crew of working-class underdogs taking on a very wealthy villain. The Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade even becomes part of their elaborate scheme. Neal and Del just wanted to get home. These guys are trying to pull off the biggest Thanksgiving heist in New York.
Turkey Meter: 🦃 6.0/10: The Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade is a major part of the movie. Those enormous balloons aren’t just there to entertain the crowds. The parade provides cover for the crew’s robbery, giving the holiday a starring role in the action. There’s no big family dinner or turkey carving, but when a Thanksgiving parade becomes part of a plan to steal millions, it earns a spot on the meter. The director of this one has proven to be problematic over the past few years, so calling this the best Thanksgiving movie of all time is kind of like inviting your drunk uncle over and putting him in charge of carving the turkey with an electric knife. It probably isn’t going to be pretty for anyone involved.
Where to Watch: Tower Heist is available to stream on Amazon Prime Video. You can also rent or purchase it digitally through Apple TV, Amazon Video and Fandango at Home.
Krisha (2015) | 1 hr 21 min
Why It Beats Planes, Trains and Automobiles: Krisha (Krisha Fairchild) shows up at her family’s Texas home for Thanksgiving, hoping to reconnect with relatives she hasn’t seen in years. Unfortunately, she’s carrying plenty of personal baggage, and her arrival makes an already complicated family gathering even more uncomfortable. As she tries to help prepare the holiday meal, old tensions begin bubbling to the surface. The turkey is in the oven and the family is doing its best to pretend everything is fine. That doesn’t last long.
Director Trey Edward Shults actually filmed the movie with members of his own family, giving this intensely personal drama an uncomfortable sense of authenticity. Planes, Trains and Automobiles makes Thanksgiving travel look like a nightmare. Krisha reminds us that sometimes the people waiting at the destination are the real reason you need a vacation.
Turkey Meter: 🦃 9.5/10: Thanksgiving is practically another character in this movie. The story unfolds over a single holiday gathering, with the family trying to get through the day without somebody losing their temper. The closer they get to sitting down for the meal, the more uncomfortable things become. If your Thanksgiving has ever involved relatives pretending not to be angry with one another, Krisha might hit a little too close to home.
Where to Watch: You can stream Krisha free with ads on Tubi, The Roku Channel, Plex and Fandango at Home. You can also rent it digitally through Amazon Prime Video or Apple TV.
Dutch (1991) | 1 hr 47 min
Why It Beats Planes, Trains and Automobiles: Dutch Dooley (Ed O’Neill) is a working-class guy dating a wealthy woman whose son, Doyle (Ethan Embry), is away at a snooty prep school. When Dutch offers to bring the kid home for Thanksgiving, he probably imagines earning a few brownie points with his girlfriend. Instead, he gets stuck on a cross-country road trip with a spoiled teenager who thinks he’s beneath him. Doyle makes it clear that he wants nothing to do with Dutch, and the trip quickly turns into a battle of wills.
Written and produced by John Hughes, Dutch borrows the mismatched-travel-companion setup that made Planes, Trains and Automobiles such a hit, but gives it a different family dynamic. The two eventually have to figure out how to tolerate each other before Thanksgiving dinner, and Dutch discovers that getting the kid home may be the easy part.
Turkey Meter: 🦃 7.5/10: Thanksgiving is the finish line for this entire road trip. Dutch and Doyle are trying to make it home in time for the family dinner, so the holiday gives their journey a real purpose. You don’t get quite as much turkey-focused screen time as you do in Home for the Holidays or Pieces of April, but at least the movie remembers what holiday everyone is traveling for.
Where to Watch: Here’s the frustrating part: Dutch isn’t currently listed on the major subscription streaming or digital rental services. If you want to watch it this Thanksgiving, you’ll likely have to track down a DVD through retailers such as Barnes & Noble or Amazon. Or check YouTube to see if a Slime Tutorial is floating around there.
Squanto: A Warrior’s Tale (1994) | 1 hr 42 min
Why It Beats Planes, Trains and Automobiles: Forget missed connections at O’Hare. Squanto (Adam Beach) has a much bigger problem: he’s been taken from his homeland by English explorers and shipped across the Atlantic. After enduring captivity in England, he finally gets an opportunity to return to North America, where he faces another dangerous journey through the wilderness. Along the way, he encounters hostile settlers and wildlife that make a broken-down rental car look like a minor inconvenience.
Directed by Xavier Koller, this Disney adventure turns the trip home into a 17th-century survival story. Squanto has a lot more to overcome than Neal and Del Griffith, and his journey eventually brings him to the events surrounding the Pilgrims’ first Thanksgiving.
Turkey Meter: 🦃 7.0/10: The movie doesn’t spend its entire runtime preparing for Thanksgiving. Much of the story follows Squanto’s abduction, his time in England and his struggle to make it back home. However, the story builds toward the Pilgrims and Native Americans sharing the harvest that became associated with the first Thanksgiving. You won’t find a traditional holiday dinner scene here, but the historical connection earns it a respectable score. And it makes the perfect companion double feature if you are going with Addams Family Values.
Where to Watch: You can stream Squanto: A Warrior’s Tale on Disney+. It’s also available to rent or purchase digitally through Amazon Prime Video, Apple TV and Fandango at Home.
Buzzard Hollow Beef (2017) | 1 hr 15 min
Why It Beats Planes, Trains and Automobiles: A family heads out to the country for a Thanksgiving getaway, hoping to enjoy a little time together away from the usual holiday madness. Their hosts seem a little strange, but that’s the least of their problems. After eating some questionable holiday meat, the family starts experiencing bizarre hallucinations, paranoia and a steadily worsening sense that something is very wrong. What begins as an awkward Thanksgiving visit turns into a psychedelic folk-horror nightmare.
At just 75 minutes, Buzzard Hollow Beef doesn’t waste much time getting weird. Planes, Trains and Automobiles gives you the nightmare of traveling with an irritating stranger. This one gives you the nightmare of accepting dinner from people you probably shouldn’t trust.
Turkey Meter: 🦃 6.5/10: Thanksgiving is the reason this family is gathered in the first place, but somebody apparently forgot to order the turkey. Beef takes center stage instead, and the holiday getaway goes off the rails after the family eats the tainted meat. It still earns points for the rural Thanksgiving setting and the increasingly uncomfortable dinner situation. Just remember to ask what’s really on the plate before going back for seconds. This one also has an award-winning performance from Portland’s own Doug Perkins. Which might be enough to make it the best Thanksgiving movie alone. But probably not.
Where to Watch: You can stream Buzzard Hollow Beef free with ads on The Roku Channel. It’s also available to rent or buy digitally through Google Play and YouTube.
A Charlie Brown Thanksgiving (1973) | 25 min
Why It Beats Planes, Trains and Automobiles: Honorable mention, since this is a short and not a feature-length movie. I was contractually obligated to include it on this list. Charlie Brown has a Thanksgiving problem. Peppermint Patty invites herself, Marcie and Franklin over for dinner, leaving poor Chuck scrambling to put together a holiday feast. Snoopy and Woodstock step in as the chefs, but their idea of Thanksgiving dinner is a little different from what the guests had in mind. What follows is one of the most wonderfully ridiculous holiday meals ever served on television.
There’s a lot to love here, including Vince Guaraldi’s unmistakable jazz soundtrack and the kind of warm, nostalgic Peanuts charm that makes you feel like you’ve been watching this special every Thanksgiving since 1973. It also gets right to the holiday without making you sit through an entire day of missed flights, broken-down cars and John Candy trying to get home. Planes, Trains and Automobiles may have the bigger laughs, but Charlie Brown delivers a concentrated dose of Thanksgiving in just 25 minutes. That’s a pretty good deal.
Turkey Meter: 🦃 9.5/10: This special practically has Thanksgiving stamped on its forehead. There’s football, a history lesson about the Mayflower, and a holiday dinner that takes place around a ping-pong table. The only thing keeping it from a perfect score is the menu. Snoopy serves toast, popcorn, pretzels and jelly beans. It’s a feast, technically, but somebody should probably call the health department.
Where to Watch: You can stream A Charlie Brown Thanksgiving exclusively on Apple TV. Apple has become the home of the Peanuts holiday specials, so you’ll need a subscription to revisit Charlie Brown’s unconventional Thanksgiving dinner this year. Or you could just go look for the Slime Tutorial on YouTube.
Why Planes, Trains and Automobiles Wins
After putting all these Thanksgiving contenders through the Gobble-Ometer, I think we can finally settle the argument. If we’re judging by critical reception, audience approval, box-office performance and lasting pop-culture influence, Planes, Trains and Automobiles still has the strongest overall claim to the Thanksgiving crown.
There are movies with higher Rotten Tomatoes scores, but some barely qualify as Thanksgiving movies. Knives Out, for example, has a 97% critic score, while Rocky sits at 95%. Both have Thanksgiving connections, but neither revolves around the holiday. John Hughes’ 1987 comedy makes getting home for Thanksgiving the entire point of its 92-minute runtime. Every missed connection, disastrous rental car and increasingly ridiculous encounter brings Neal Page and Del Griffith closer to the holiday dinner they’re desperately trying to reach.
It also has something that’s difficult to measure with a review score: staying power. Nearly 40 years after its release, the movie remains a Thanksgiving tradition for countless families, and its most memorable lines have become part of the pop-culture vocabulary. That combination of critical respect and lasting recognition makes it awfully difficult for another Thanksgiving movie to knock it off the throne.
The Whiteside Theater got it right. Planes, Trains and Automobiles is the best Thanksgiving movie of all time. Why did I even doubt it? Y’all say it with me now: “Those aren’t pillows!”