Movies

‘You’ve Got Mail’ Is Getting a Remake, But Are Email Romances Still a Thing, Grandpa?

You've got mail remake

Warner Bros. is going back to the inbox with a new take on You’ve Got Mail, the 1998 romantic comedy that helped turn anonymous online correspondence into a big-screen love story. Jason Orley, director of I Want You Back and Big Time Adolescence, is attached to direct the project and write its current draft.

But nearly 30 years after Tom Hanks and Meg Ryan fell for each other through email, there’s a pretty big question hanging over this remake: Do people still fall in love that way?

The new film’s story details are being kept under wraps, so it’s too early to know how Warner Bros. plans to bring the premise into the present. Dating apps have changed the way people meet online, while social media and direct messaging have made digital conversations part of everyday life. Email no longer has the same sense of discovery it did in 1998. Back then, getting a message from someone you barely knew could feel like the beginning of something special. Today, that kind of connection has a lot more competition.

Orley is working from a screenplay by Deborah Kaplan and Harry Elfont, the writing team behind Can’t Hardly Wait and Josie and the Pussycats. The pair also wrote Made of Honor and Leap Year. Neal Moritz and Tania Landau are producing through Original Film.

Nora Ephron’s original You’ve Got Mail starred Ryan as Kathleen Kelly, an independent children’s bookstore owner in New York whose business is threatened by a massive chain bookstore run by Joe Fox (Hanks). The two become rivals in person, unaware that they’re also anonymous online pen pals who have been falling for each other through their email exchanges.

The film arrived in December 1998 and became a major box-office success, earning more than $250 million worldwide. It was the third movie pairing for Hanks and Ryan, following Joe Versus the Volcano (one of my personal favorite movies of all time) and Sleepless in Seattle (which I haven’t seen since it came out, but also seems quite dated now), and their final collaboration with Ephron, though they have worked together in the more recent past. Tom had a cameo in Meg’s directorial debut, Ithaca.

There is another interesting wrinkle to the remake’s premise. You’ve Got Mail was already a modern update of an earlier love story. The film drew from Miklós László’s play Parfumerie and the 1940 movie adaptation The Shop Around the Corner. The earlier story used letters to connect its romantic leads, while Ephron’s version brought that correspondence into the emerging world of email. The challenge now is finding the equivalent for an audience that grew up with smartphones. Maybe What’s App? Or Insta DMs? Who know where they will take this. I like a good romantic comedy, so I’ll be there regardless. As long as it’s not about single people getting to have sex on just one single sanctioned day. Who’d make a movie like that? Sounds ridiculous.

Orley has some experience with contemporary romantic comedies. He directed Amazon’s I Want You Back, starring Charlie Day, Jenny Slate and Gina Rodriguez. His next feature, Close Personal Friends, is an Amazon comedy starring Brie Larson, Jack Quaid, Lily Collins and Henry Golding. Kaplan and Elfont also have plenty of experience with the genre, making them familiar collaborators for a project that needs to find a new way into a familiar story.

For now, Warner Bros. hasn’t announced a cast or revealed how the new version will handle its central romance. The original found something exciting in a technology that was still relatively new to everyday life. Its successor will have to find that same spark in a world where meeting someone online is hardly unusual.